Wednesday, June 4, 2008

The famed query and the Telecom Revolution :P

I am running short of time. Hence cant come up with an original update. :)

Heading to Nepal for a week. Will be back on 10th June.

Till then, an interesting read.

2-3 years back, one fachcha (junior in IIMA parlance and nowadays, MBA parlance itself) asked the following query. Read 'em and most importantly, read the whacky reply she got from the senior. Hilarious. :)

Query:

i need a cell cuz i want to stay in touch with my guy. also i may not be in my room/ be able to come to my room to make/take calls at all times, but i can always carry my cell with
me anywhere!!
ofcourse i will get std activated... but messagin u can do only thru a cell...

i get teh point abt matchin networks to reduce cost... n here is my dilemma

my guy has an airtel connection
my dad has a reliance phone
my brother has idea
and our home phone is a tata indicom.

now what???

i need to have teh most cost effective way out... which wd be covenient fr my parents, bro and guy too!!

help!!!


*Now below is the reply to the above post...*
* The reply was by a now PGP-4 or a 2007 IIMA passout and the query was from a 2008 passout when she was going to join IIM A*

This is a very good query. I also faced a lot of problems when I came to IIMA because I wanted to stay in touch with my guy, bhains and bakri (If I had an elephant, it would have been a simple matter of making a trunk call). Considering the reverence that Indian culture accords to the bovine and the divine, staying in touch with cattle is a very important issue. One needs to only read the Hindi stories of Munshi Premchand, such as Heera Moti and Godaan to realize the deep bonds that people in the cowbelt have for their livestock. Of course, calling Munshi Premchand a Hindi writer is slightly misleading
because his writings have a proliferation of Urdu words, reflecting the degree of intermixing between Urdu and Hindi in pre-independence Uttar Pradesh. The alphabet taught in schools during those days began with Aliph, which interestingly is a derivative of the Greek alpha,which had first made its presence felt in India during the times of
Alexander and Selecus Nicator. And perhaps it is divine happenstance that Alexander the Great had to retreat from the Ganges, thereby completing the UP connection. However the Greek influence in India did not die out with him, his generals if you are still reading this
then I can only wonder how exciting your work is established mini kingdoms from whatever they could salvage of his victories and particularly interesting is the case of the kingdom of Bactria (in present day Afghanistan) , a Greek island in a South Asian sea. The
great king Menander of Bactria is the same Milinda, the celebrated king who had a dialogue with the Buddhist sage Nagasena on the semantics of being.

But let me not digress from the core issue, which is your connectivity query. Well as you know, India has undergone a telecom revolution in the past 10 years or so. It all began with the reaking down of the monoploy of the Department of Telecommunications (DoT)
and the establishment of quasi-autonomous bodies like the MTNL and the VSNL. For the purpose of cellular communications, India is divided into a number of contiguous circles, which roughly correspond to the boundaries of the states (which is very convenient considering that the states of India were reorganized on a linguistic basis in the 1950s, thus going to ahow how farsighted our planners and statesmen were at the time). Initially, for reasons of viable competition, each circle could have 2 private operators and one network from either MTNL or BSNL. At the moment, I think 3 private operators are allowed and plans are to allow a further private player in a circle.

So what you need to do is, locate a map of India, find the telecom cirlces and identify the players operating there. Formulate a matrix to display this information and then apply the concepts of cost minimization (modified simplex method) to identify the optimal network combination for your needs.

Cheers,
PGP-4

ROTFL. :)

The guy replied must have been one heck of genius ;)

I hope someone asks something similar next year and I get a nice time. :P

Or better, someone asks this year itself and a PGP2 sends a gem. ;)

Monday, June 2, 2008

Wanna become a CEO? Work on your hairstyle

http://specials.rediff.com/money/2008/may/14ceo1.htm

Indra Nooyi


What has hairstyle got to do with success? There is a hair raising observation among corporate America that most of the successful CEOs including Pepsico's Indra Nooyi part their hair to the left, says US business magazine Fortune.


Warren Buffett


Legendary investor and chief executive of Berkshire Hathaway Warren Buffett also parts his hair to the left. The report said that he comes across as the classic left-brainer: rational and assertive.


Jamie Dimon


Jamie Dimon of investment bank J P Morgan Chase also joins the 'left-parted' club of highly efficient CEOs who comb their hair to the left side. In recent years, a pseudoscience has emerged around the theory that left-partedness signals leadership potential, while parting on the right suggest something a little off-kilter, Fortune said.


Rick Wagoner


A look at the CEOs of Fortune 500 companies reveals only three among the top CEOs of 50 firms, part their hair on their right side. They include General Motors' chairman Rick Wagoner.


Lloyd C. Blankfein


Meanwhile, in the Fortune 500 there are highly successful chief executives who neither part their hair to the left or right. Such names include General Electrics Jeff Immlet, Goldman Sachs' Lloyd Blankfein.

According to the magazine, Walter is credited with the theory (of parting hair to left) three decades ago, after he discovered that only a few American presidents parted their hair on the right.


Rediff articles are hilarious and only thing to beat that would be the comments the readers make!!

One rare out of the blue sensible comment:

The author does not provide figures of the proportion of the general population which parts its hair to the left. One just needs to walk downtown and see for oneself the proportion of population parting hair to the left. Common... u fellas ... we all know that the default option is to part hair to the left. No doubt most CEOs are from that group. If i study the number of convicts on death row the most likely outcome would be 'Most part to the left', just as with CEOs.
So i suggest rediff ponders into the details of such research and provide evidence based findings rather than make eyecatching headlines. Unfortunately, eyecatching phrases seem to dominate and apear to be rediff's mantra on certain occasions. Isnt this daft....

And oops! I part my hair right. I just lost a easy CEO berth. :(

Sunday, June 1, 2008

IIMs vs US B schools

I had posted a reply to this query at GMATclub/PG. Standard disclaimers apply.

Query Post:


It will be great if some of you guys can share your perspective/suggestions on my quandary.

1) Is IIM better than top US Bschools in terms of prospects?

I know it depends on a plethora of variables, especially boils down to 'where' I want to be.
Lets just say that I am equally open to continue in the states or pack my bags to India. In terms of ROI, you can repay the loan ~3 yrs out of an ivy league.

2) What can IIM actually do to your career?

Well, I am not talking about the few outliers who make ~$400K straight out of IIM. Where do average people land up? I am frankly concerned about making ~12L p.a after two years when my current pay is way ahead (even after taking the geographic variation into consideration)

Ultimately, I want to transition from tech to management oriented roles (strategy) and I am looking for a MBA to open those doors for me. So the question comes to - Which MBA will make more sense at this point in my career! I really wish I knew the answer to this. But the good thing is - I still have ~2 months to decide

My Reply:

Views are strictly mine. Biased and whatever. I thought of chipping in from whatever research I had done.

1) Is IIM better than top US Bschools in terms of prospects?

We need to look at this from a different point of view. If you can get an admit from the top 7 (HSW, Chichago GSB, MIT, Kellogg, Columbia) I would say its much better to do from there, mainly from the experience point of view. Whether you will get a better job is a difft issue (it depends on your relative standing in class in terms of profile). But it will open more doors in terms of intl network, alumni being in senior position etc, reputed brand names internationally etc.

From 8 to 15 rank: Tough to say. One needs to take a call. Very very subjective. Though I would still say do an US MBA mainly for the experience and not in terms of prospects. Prospects are again relative. If you have a wonderful profile and can get a I Bank/Mgmt consulting shortlist (which is very competitive in B Schools ranked 8 to 15) do from US. Else, chances of getting a shortlist from I banks/Mgmt consulting in IIM ABC may be higher.

From 15+ rank: IIM ABC would be better in terms of chances. i.e. If you have a very good profile, getting into I Bank/Mgmt consulting from IIM ABC would be easier than from those instis.

But remember one important thing. From IIMs most students join an I Bank or a Mgmt consulting firm as an analyst and after 2 years automatically become an associate. A few firms like LB, DB and Barclays have started giving associate positions. But if you get a job in an I Bank or Mgmt consulting firm from US B school you will join as an associate. Only if you have relevant work ex would you get to join from ABC as an associate whereas in US, relevant work ex is not necessary.

2) What can IIM actually do to your career?

IIM ABC: If you want to work in India, its very good to do from these since they are wonderful brand names in India and will open doors. Basically, whatever door a HSW will open in US, similar doors will open if you are from ABC in India.

If you want to work in US, ABC gives an opportunity to get a front end job there which is otherwise not possible from India. But thats it. It may still take sometime for ABC junta to establish themselves there and the brand becoming well known. If you want to make a shift away from the typical firms from wall street which recruit at IIMs, it may be difficult to land a shortlist in US since the brand name is yet to become famous.

In ABC, if your profile is good, you can make a 20 LPA+ to as high as 30-35 LPA (including bonus) in Indian I Banks. I am not considering the outlier 50 LPA+ jobs which 1-2 get in PE firms.

If you end up in tier-1 consulting, its 18 LPA-20 LPA.

General mgmt firms, tier-2 banks, non i banking banks, tier-2 mgmt consulting etc from the industry pay less. 10-16 LPA with 10-14 LPA being the norm.

I have written above mainly from career perspective since that was your question. Learning environment in top 15 US B schools would definitely be better than from IIM ABC due to the fact that most students would have work ex and discussions in class will be better and more insightful. ABC is also slowly shifting towards people with more work ex. A few years back, 60% of a class were freshers. These days its dropped to 30%. However, it will still take a lot of time to catch up with the methodology of US B schools.

In Each of the IIMs, ABC, you would find top 30-40 students who, if they had maybe worked for 3-4 years, can get into HSW. The stud profile guys. The ones who topped their schools, got offers from MIT, Stan for MS, Represented India in olympiads at Russia and types, State level sportsmen, started NGO's, 9 pointers out of 10, Worked at DB, LB, Mck etc in India (which is not easy), Full scholarships during college etc, top 100-300 JEE rankers. Whatever they have done, they have been really good in those. They usually join IIM ABC within 0-2 years of work ex. The topmost 1-4 of these guys join PE firms like Blackstone, Apax, Caryle, Sun group and likes these days and make insane money similar to PE firms in US.

However this group, once they work for 3-4 years, they don't apply to IIMs. They apply to HSW and usually are the desis who make to H & S and the remaining top schools. But the 3-4 yrs of work experience would bring in a lot more perspective and maturity towards life and hence the learnings would be better. But they join IIMs earlier and miss out on those.

Post made at Pagalguy about my GDPI's & my Profile

Hi everybody,

Finally the devil gets its dew.

Here's My profile and calls:

Acads:

Xth: 86.7 TN Matriculation
XIIth: 95.1 TN State Board
Grad: 8.17/10
College, Year: NIT Trichy, 2005
Discipline: Electrical and Electronics Engineering

Extra Currics:

Pretty decent: College Placement rep, Many quizzes, Dance, Drama etc

CAT Percentiles:

QA: 99.00
DI: 95.64
VA: 99.73

Overall: 99.81

Work Ex:

L&T Design -> 6 months
L&T Sales -> 16 months
Milagrow, A mgmt consulting start-up, directly reporting to CEO, amazing work -> 7 months

Total work ex: 29 months (My strongest point and my differentiating factor)

Calls: BLACKI + S

Attended: BLACKI

Converts: ABLIK (WL 31 at A which got converted)
Rejects: C

Joining: A

A:

Essay: Pretty shoddy work
PI: Very mediocre
Verdict: WL 31
Did I expect this? : No. I was expecting a reject
What would have attracted them: Probably my work profile

B:

GD+Essays: Good job done. SOP/Form was very good.
PI: I would say extremely good. Spoke very passionately and convincingly. They looked pretty impressed. I had clear thoughts on MBA's, Career paths etc
Verdict: Selected
Did I expect this: Yes

C:

GD: Good
PI: Pretty good and chill.
Verdict: Reject
Did I expect this?: No. I thought it will be a easy convert.
What would have bugged them: I asked about culture at C and asked the reason why its pretty chill etc. They became defensive. I felt it was a bad move from my side. But still feel an interview must not have been judged by that. Rest of my interview was chill. I could not figure out any other reason for reject.

L:

GD: Crappy topic. All spoke non sense
Essay: Again crappy topic and crappy essay
PI: Boring and uninteresting. Fully on economics. But did okayishly on a few topics.
Verdict: Selected
Did I expect this? : Not initially. I was initially expecting a reject. Then heard students with high percentiles usually convert L. Then became optimistic and thought will convert L.

I:

GD: Business case study. My strong area. Cracked it majorly.
PI: On my L&T technical work ex and Tamil Nadu history. Did decently here for sure.
Verdict: Selected
Did I expect this: Yes

K:

GD: Fishmarket. Told some 1-2 good points
PI: Clean sweep. I almost interviewed them for our start-up. Too chill. They treated me like a mature guy and gave due respect to my work exp etc.
Verdict: Selected
Did I expect this: 100%. I had no doubts. I told my friends that everyone may reject me, but not IIM K.

How things went for me:

My strength was the forms. I had clarity of thought on what I wanted to do and my work exp etc was very good. So, where ever I filled forms, and more importantly the panelists read it seriously, I had good chances. They formed a biased positive opinion about me before interview started and it made my job easy. It happened majorly at K, to some extent at B and I. A and C, surprisingly did not bother much about the form and that was disadvantageous for me. L form was pretty useless for me since no qns had to be answered.

My 3 strong points:

-work ex (job profile: start-up, mgmt consulting, reporting to CEO etc + L&T work ex)
-Can speak very well. No problem in conversing/communicating.
- Very good idea about all post MBA careers, MBA life, types of schools, how I want to achieve whatever I have set out for etc. So, typically they would not have heard any kiddish answers from me. (I had worked on preparing for an US MBA. That requires a person to have a good understanding of all this.)

Mail on CAT preparation

I received a mail from a close family friend as follows. Edited to protect privacy.

Dear Pradeep

X is doing his final year (2008 to 2009) in ECE, from PSG Kovai.

Kindly advise what he should do next and guide him to also to be successful.

Many thanks and kind regards,

Y

My reply. May be beneficial to few.

Dear Uncle,

It is the right time for him. He can do the following:

1. First is to get a feel whether he wants to do an MBA. There are many who are interested in MS from US/MTech from IISc. He would know better. MS must not be done just with the idea of entering into US. If he genuinely wants to work in the technical sector, he needs to do one. GATE is a good exam to join IISc in India for MTech. But he has to secure in the AIR top 10-200 (depending on the course) to secure a seat at IISc. Its not as tough as it seems. Dedicated efforts can get him there.

2. In case he feels MBA is something he wants to do, for e.g. he gets interested reading Economic Times or news related to business etc, then he can look at an MBA. He need not close GRE/GATE as options. But its better to decide earlier whether he wants to pursue a technical career or pursue a career in business related fields.

3. There is again the question of whether he actually is interested in higher studies. But then, I wont attack it here. He is in final year and will have an idea about these.

4. I am now assuming he is interested in an Indian MBA from one of the top 10 institutes and proceeding further.

5. The CAT'08 exam would be held in Nov 2nd week sunday. This has been the norm.

6. IIMs, SPJAIN, NITIE, FMS, XLRI, MDI Gurgaon, IIFT, IIT Bombay are some of the good colleges (in no particular order.)

7. He first has to get some books from some of his class mates/college mates at PSG. There will always be a bunch of people preparing for CAT seriously in the final year and who would have joined come classes

8. He has to join a Mock CAT series from one of the leading instis. 3 of the famous coaching centres conducting these are TIME, IMS, Career Launcher. I would advice to join TIME test series. If possible, better to join 2 test series if the time does not overlap.

9. Its important to understand where he stands in these tests based on his natural intelligence. There is no need that everyone from PSG/NITT/Anna will do well in these tests. But the chances are definitely higher since the students supposedly belong to better colleges.

10. He must average out in 4-5 tests and understand where he stands. That is judged thru percentiles. Percentile means what percentage of students did you beat. If one secures 99 %ile, then he belongs to the top 1%age of the test takers.

General guidelines (consistent performance is assumed) -

a. 98%ile and above in TIME test series with 95%ile + in each section (there are usually 3 sections) : Good score and student is already ready to get into IIMs. He has to just work harder and work on his strategy to perfect it

b. 95-98%ile or 98%ile+ but problems with 1 section -> Potential definitely there to get into IIMs. Hardwork is necessary and if he works hard can start touching 98+ scores. Identification of weak areas is crucial.

c. 90-95%ile -> Okayish scores. Definitely needs to work very hard for IIMs. More hardwork and dedication needed to crack it. Must improve on weak areas.

d. Less than 90%iles -> Less scores. Not easy. Though many have done it through hardwork. A lot of hardwork and genuine introspection needed whether he is capable of scoring a 98+. Else, need to apply to many other colleges if MBA is needed. IIMs are tough, but definitely nothing is impossible.

11. When starting to prepare, its normal for people to be in class 'd' as above and move on slowly to class 'a' with preparation and hardwork. Class 'a' means chances of conversion are very high. But luck plays a crucial role too. Its a 150 min test and every mark counts.

12. Not to get de motivated by low scores initially. It happens to everyone.

13. Read newspapers daily and keep track of whats happening around. Better to be smart and well read. Not to crack CAT, generally its high time one develops those qualities before entering corporate world. It will keep him in good stead.

14. For getting calls from all 6 IIMs, I think a score of 99.5%ile overall and a 96%ile+ in each section would be appropriate. Though people with lesser scores also get calls from fewer IIMs. Very few get calls for less than 98.5%ile. Sectional cut-offs are "extremely important". No point in scoring 99.90%ile overall with a less than 90%ile in one section. Probably no IIM will call him.

15. He would know what the 3 sections are etc from his class mates.

Once he gets IIM calls, we can discuss about Group Discussion/Personal Interviews etc. Good reading habits will help him there.

I hope it was helpful. Everyone will give many advices and "paths to get into IIMs" and all. Over a period of time, I guess he will become intelligent enough to develop his own methodology for this test.

Finally, many have a bad day in these tests. His intelligence need not be judged by this test. Its not a perfect test to measure that. There is too much of randomness involved in it.

All the best for him. He can contact me when any help is needed. Its important to give CAT'08 to understand where he stands.

Great Programs

One of these 3 Programs which I may wish to do in my life at some point in time. More for the opportunity it gives to study in these great schools than anything else.

http://www.gsb.stanford.edu/sloan/
http://mitsloan.mit.edu/fellows/
http://www.london.edu/sloanfellowship.html

Around 10-15 yrs work ex necessary for the 10-12 month programs.

Saturday, May 31, 2008

Reply from WIMWI passout on my queries

I have put this mail up here to the benefit of all. Standard disclaimers apply. Edited it to correct spelling mistakes and to make it more readable. Its not that this mail made me join A. I also edited it to remove certain very minor comparisons with other B Schools and have the part which only talks about IIMA.

I am posting it as a for-your-information-only. Hope it benefits few.

QUOTE:

Expectations out of MBA:

- Learning general biz stuff will happen in both A&B. However A has some fantastic electives in both finance and strategy and you can rest assured that you will have ample choice.

- Sitting in classes of superb profs in my view is the biggest strength of A. If someone asks me why is A so different from others enjoying such a brand value, I always say its because of the profs. I have never witnessed such genius personalities and trust me, You will enjoy the aura of intellect thoroughly in the classes. All brand value, placements, rankings...all of these are after effects.....the foundation is that A has some excellent profs in all fields who will simply blow you away with their expereience and depth of knowledge. Prof Ajay Pandey, prof Seb Morris, Prof Abraham Koshy, are just few examples u can search on the net about !

- Good CGPA.....IIMA is absolutely the place to come if u are interested in academics. Period. Acads is clearly the first preference here and everything else depends on student's enthu. You can do everything else as well but thats only after acads. The peers r simply brilliant here and hence the level of competition is absolutely unimaginable. But that inspires you to study harder and get good grades. Little bit of RG and all happens but that happens everywhere n you can't run away from that. In fact its good coz u will face such pressures in work as well n hence this is a great dress rehearsal ! IIMA is also known as IIM Acads. And if u have a good CGPA, well you are the bond then :)

- Get a good job---well, I need not say anything here. The variety is immense. You can check our placement report I posted on PG. Don't even waste a second having doubts on placements. It can get better than this place. Period.

- Learn 1-2 games/sports : Even though IIMA is lot about acads, the best thing is that the opportunities to do whatever u want to are infinite. Its all about managing your time. We have about 40 odd clubs ranging from lits to sports to bike riding to movies :) And trust me , we all do everything along with studies. It just makes u an all rounder :) Frisbee, Cricket, Badminton, TT, Football, Volleyball....All are extremely popular sports here....We even got a foosball table this year :) U can learn whatever sports you want :)

- Peer n/w : The junta in IIMA is the top cream of the country. The amount of intellect around you is mind blowing. And hence you need not bother at all about the peer n/w.

- Work Ex/Mature junta : See, in every institute, u will have a bunch of guys who just wanna pass 2 yrs, and get a good job and then there will always be those who are here for learning and chose courses seriously to gain the max out of the place. And finally there are those who want to do both. I was in the last category :) So the thing is that its completely up to what you want out of the place. You can take all fundoo subjects and you will get good junta to support you and have some intelligent discussions with u and if you get tired u can chose some easy subject to relax. The onus is fully on you. You will always find a sect who will be there to take and learn good course. So don't have any doubts on that.

As far as work ex is concerned I can tell you that the %age of work ex people is steadily on the rise in A and my junior batch has much more work ex people than my batch. Plus I have learnt that its not always true that higher no. of work ex guys implies higher level of intellect n maturity in discussions.

So don't go so much on the figures of no of work ex guys. The quality of work ex guys is more important and thats where IIMA scores above all instis.

Doubts about IIMA :

- Balance in both years -----Thats the biggest misconception people have. See, the thing is that since the first year is so grueling, that many people want to chillax in 2 year which u can afford coz theres no compulsion in the subjects u chose. However, that does not imply that u cant chose good subjects in 2 year and study with the same tempo in 2 year. I have known people who took equally demanding but good subjects in 2 year as well :)

Its simple - Its fully upto you. Both years can be academically demanding or 2nd year can be chill. Its completely a personal preference. Insti allows you to do both. And u should'nt worry at all !

- Profiling - As i said earlier, don't go on sheer nos. See the quality as well. Trust me, you will find the best of minds and personalities in A. And forget just acads, there are all rounders galore here.You will find swimming champs, national tennis players, Music band members, professional singers, professional bikers, debaters...you name it you got it ! Every guy in IIMA has a special talent apart from acads and am not kidding ! What more do u want in terms of learning environment !! Its all upto you how you harness the environment to gain max benefit.

Overall, whatever said and done IIMA's brand value is impossible to match and that brand value is the result of quality of faculty and students. Hence I would strongly recommend you to shed all inhibitions coz none of them hold good from my 2 yrs at IIMA and 2 yrs before that in preparing and comparing B Schools extensively :)

Congrats for your achievement and I hope you don't make the mistake of rejecting A for the doubts you had mentioned because they don't hold much water when you see how IIMA is in 2 years :)

Lemme know if I can be of any other help !

Hope to se ya in IIMA sometime in the next 2 years if I do make a visit :)

All the best !

UNQUOTE