Wednesday, June 18, 2008

Good old marketing: Where are thou?

I recently visited Pantaloons to get some dresses. They were running a sale or something which sounded like "buy for Rs 1000 and get a 7.5% discount voucher". I knew these discount voucher scams. Unless one reads the fine print you can assume its a lost case. Some usual '*conditions apply' are:

1. You may have to buy from 22nd June to 26th June (meaning a very small window and probably one would not notice that)

2. You have to buy for Rs 2000 minimum to avail the discount (which effectively means you have to buy for Rs 1000+Rs 2000 to avail the discount)

3. You cannot use the discount coupon to buy t shirts, shirts, peter england ties, levis jeans and excalibur suits (self explanatory. Closes off many obvious purchases)

I was aware of all these tactics and thought let me read the fine print at Pantaloons to make sure of what I am getting into. And boy! I was shocked!

Good thing was that it was not technically fine print. They had put up a large poster with the rules for using discount coupon which went something like this.

1. For every 1000 Rs purchase one would get a 7.5% discount coupon which can be used in the next purchase
2. One can club 2 discount coupons maximum for buying red tagged dresses
3. One can club 4 discount coupons maximum for buying green tagged dresses
4. One can use only 1 discount coupon for buying yellow tagged dresses
5. One can use 2 discount coupons maximum for buying deos, belts, ties, handkerchiefs and other accessories
6. Irrespective of number of discount coupons maximum amount to which discount can be applied is Rs 10000
7. However, no grey tagged dresses can be discounted using the discount vouchers
8. 4 more points of the same order

I was reminded of those puzzling questions which used to come in CAT Data Interpretation section and also of those good ol' George Summers puzzles.

I could not figure out what the marketing manager was thinking when he devised this "ingenius sale". Did the marketing manager actually think that some 40 year old auntie will go through this whole thing, figure out the convoluted 12 point rule book and then understand which dresses she must buy.

Ridiculous. I can actually imagine a few MBA's doing an all nighter coming up with these "smart" sale strategy and making a nice PPT to the senior management. I guess they would have also used some complicated regression analysis. It all sounds so dilbertish. :P


Interesting Quote-1

"When building a team, I always search first for people who love to win. If I can't find enough of those, I look for people who hate to lose."

- Ross Perot, founder of Electronic Data Systems

Saturday, June 14, 2008

Dasavatharam: Where is the story?

1. The first thing which I felt after the film got over was "When he had spent so much time on make-up and graphics etc, he should have pondered a bit more about something called the story"

2. I really felt sorry for Kamal. The movie genuinely sucked after all the hard work he had put.

3. No story + Bad humour killed it

4. This hopefully must be Himesh's last Tamil film. He did not get the pulse of the audience one bit. I don't expect him to either. Anyway, I don't know whose pulse would have found the music good.

Watch the film as a normal time pass film and not with "the" expectations one usually has for Kamal films.

Friday, June 13, 2008

Where is the Business Sense?

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/Business/India_Business/Ranbaxy_sell-off_a_shock_for_industry/articleshow/3121585.cms

As one of India’s earliest entrepreneurial companies to stop the march of multinational drug companies, does the sale mark an end of era in pharmaceutical industry.


I don't understand this whole "patriotic" angle to Ranbaxy junta selling of their stake. The media has made it into a "Indian MNC" is "bought out" by Japanese firm and its a "Blow" to the Indian Industry.

Yeah, we do feel proud when our Tatas bought out Corus and likes. Somehow we likened it to the kind of frenzy we have for Cricket. The way our people were happy when we won Pakistan in cricket when the Kargil war was going on.

But how stupid can the media get? I thought its a blow to the Singh's only if the valuation they sold it for or something like that did not make sense.

Firstly, Malvinder's logic was simple. He did not see how the firm will grow comfortably beyond 2012. He was not confident. Now this logic must have been attacked. Maybe one could have thought if Malvinder was not the CEO and someone else became, can it add more value to the shareholders and likes.

Secondly, there should be more discussion on the price paid.

Instead there are really stupid ideas given by these newspapers as if the owners committed some crime and let down India in the global arena.

Yuck.

Thursday, June 12, 2008

Gurgaon and its advantages

Going on 12th June to PVR cinemas to book 4 tickets for Dasavathaaram for a Saturday afternoon show (14th June) and the guy at the ticket counter asks "Is the last but 3rd row fine with you"

Its bliss. :)

CFA Level-1 Part II

I posted this in an Orkut community. I hope its useful to someone here.

I attended the exam in Nepal. Exams started and ended sharply at correct time.

I feel I have done well. Lets see.

I would say they tested the basic fundas to the core. They did not touch advanced fundas much. If one had read the books well and thoroughly, it would have definitely been easier. Solving a few qp's would have given an idea. CFAI mocks for 100$ resembled the main exam though main exam was easier than CFAI mocks. Schweser mocks were unnecessarily tough and did not focus much on the "basics" part whcih CFA tested. Numericals were very less in main exam. Second session was slightly more difficult than 1st. I found ethics tricky in 2nd.

I would definitely say that if one prepares and is willing to slog (to remember the many concepts) it is a passable exam. If one takes it lightly and skims thru the text (schweser), you may lose out on a few qns.

I thought the most deadly questions in ethics were those were we have to identify the type of violation. 4 options were given and one of them least likely violated it. One really had to know the fundas in ethics to crack those. I already am discounting 10/36 questions in ethics since they were awesomely tricky.

I felt schweser Q Bank of 3300 questions is a much better practice ground. It tests your basics in a much better way than the book 6/book 7 exams of schweser. Book 6/ Book 7 is olympiad type of stuff which will help to understand concepts if you have time to spend on those. If one does not have time to study and does only book 6 and book 7, opportunity cost is too high. Its worth spending 100$ on the mocks. But if they dont give the mock papers to review after completing exam (they dont give as of now, so there is no way you can see the questions once test is over,only solutions can be seen), its a bit futile.

Some more points which I did not post in Orkut for PG junta:

1. Be patient while reading the questions. Dont rush thru it. Some are deceptively easy and are easy except for a word or 2 in the question. Like "annual" instead of "semi annual". "This year" vs "next year". Assuming this wrongly will give wrong answers. I made some 5-7 mistakes like this.

2. Don't skip any topic unless you don't have time. They more or less tested everything.

3. As engineers, sometimes we may concentrate more on formulas and look at theory as cut-the-crap. Dont do that. If reading from schweser, better go thru the whole text book, each line. Its just 5 books and not too tough.

4. Also, remember things these way: There will be many things in schweser which would be like: There are 3 types of .... There are 5 reasons why.... There are 6 types of risk. They are.. There are 3 types of probability.. etc Or They may not specifically quote like There are n types of... But it would be implicit in the passage. There may be some 2-5 types of things.

Remember these very well. Each point you can remember thru some code word or something. EPS, FLISKKS or whatever/however you feel like. But dont just skim thru those parts. You will find so many of those in each subject, including quants. Write them down somewhere in short form. It helps. We had many questions which were theoretical this way.


5. FSA: The SS8 and SS9 is considered tough. 2 days before the exam I made some notes which helped me.

SS9:

I drew some tree diagrams/flowchart kinda stuff. Like FIFO-> Less COGS-> More Net Income-> Better profitability. Also like DDB-> More depreciation->Less assets->Higher ROA and types.

This helped to understand how everything is linked.
I drew 1-2 tree diagrams for each topic like inventory, capitalizing etc

Also, next part is understanding restatement of financial statements when:

- Converting FIFO between LIFO
- Capitalizng vs expensing
- Operating lease was capital lease etc
- whatever to whatever

They will ask questions like if you change one from another how will it affect:

1. Balance sheet
2. Income statement
3. Cash Flow

Schweser would have given one paragraph which is lengthy while revising and you will forget soon. So, make notes of how they affect with 1-2 lines.

e.g. FIFO to LIFO for COGS (Income statement):

COGS FIFO = COGS LIFO - Change in LIFO reserve

(We got the above equation as a question but worded as a sentence)

It helps. Make such notes for each area in SS9.

SS8:

Same stuff. I/S and B/S may seem more easy when compared to Cash Flow. Please don't leave Cash Flow. Study that. There will be an example in CFAI books. Note down the formulas from that. Its very conceptual to remember too.

Would again re-edit this as and when I get time.

Wednesday, June 11, 2008

CFA Level-1 experience

I had been to Nepal recently to appear for CFA Level -1.

This post is a bit about CFA exams and the course in general, what I learnt while preparing, how to prepare etc. I would like to share my experience and hope its helpful to a few.

CFA stands for Chartered Financial Analyst. You can know a lot more about it here at their website. The exam is mainly for those who want to enter into a career in Asset Management/Portfolio Management. Mutual fund is an example of a portfolio. One can have a portfolio of stocks, bonds etc. But the exam also covers few other areas which would help one get some idea about Markets in general.

This is the syllabus one would cover if one clears all three levels. The syllabus is broken down into many parts for each level. Since the Finance profession per se does not have too many exams like those in software, CFA is considered by few as an entry ticket into the world of finance. Its considered to be a respected course and is supposedly prestigious.

Some basic facts about CFA exam:

1. There are 3 levels to complete in it. CFA Level 1, Level 2 and Level 3.

2. Unless one successfully completes all three levels one cant become a CFA charter holder. However one can definitely write in his resume CFA L 1 pass etc if he has cleared only L1 till date.

3. Level 1 is held twice in a year. June and December. Level 2 and Level 3 are held only once in a year in June.

4. So technically one can complete all 3 levels in 1.5 years. Appear for Dec'09 L1, June'10 L2 and June'11 L3.

5. Its paper and pencil test as of now and not a computer adaptive test and hence is conducted in a single day across the world (2 days actually, due to time differences).

6. The Level 1 and Level 2 papers are objective in nature with 4 options per question. Level 3 has 1 objective paper and 1 subjective paper with 10-12 case studies.

7. 30-40% of those who appear for L1 pass. Similar, but slightly higher number would pass L2. Around 2/3rd's pass L3. And totally 18% who appear for L1 finally end up as a charter holder.

8. The seemingly higher pass percentages must not make one complacent. The test is tough if you have not prepared well (pretty obvious huh? ;) )and does not depend just on intelligence. A lot of hard work needs to go behind it since there are innumerable concepts which have to remembered. Also, in western countries a number of MBA's, people who are into equity research, portfolio mgmt and other related financial industries appear for it and it can be assumed they skew the curve to create a higher pass percentage.

9. Level 1 has 120 questions in a morning 3 hour session 0900-1200 hrs and another 120 question afternoon session of 120 questions from 1400-1700 hrs. All question carry equal marks and there is no negative marking. So everyone will technically attempt all 240 questions since there is no downside. One need not pass in both the sessions. Totally out of the 240 marks, one has to cross the cut-off. Also, each session of 120 question is split into 10 parts (Actually into 6 parts since they club 2 parts into 1). But one need not pass in each part. So, all that matters for passing is what score you got out of 240. That is the "only number" considered.

Syllabi for Level -I along with weightage (in terms of no. of questions) when I gave the exam in June'08:

I. Ethical and Professional Standards - 15%

II. Quantitative Methods - 12%

III. Economics - 10%

IV. Financial Statement Analysis- 20%

V. Corporate Finance - 8%

VI. Equity Investments - 10%

VII. Fixed Income - 12%

VIII. Derivatives - 5%

IX. Alternative Investments - 3%

X. Portfolio Management - 5%


Preparation (specifically for Level-I) :

When we for the test by paying the 1000$ or whatever fees, we will get a set of 6-7 fat books from the CFAI institute. This can be used for preparation. The books are really conceptual and do a extremely good job of explaining the concepts etc. However one disadvantage with the book is its the typical "foreign author" book of engineering days. Like taking 6 full pages in size 7 font to prove Kirchoffs law. So, yes, one will definitely understand better if one reads from the CFAI books but will take hell lot of time. The other set of books is from Schweser. There are many more, but usually Schweser is good enough. Schweser does a wonderful job of cutting down the crap and reduces the size to almost 1/10th to 1/15th of the original CFAI books. This book, I would say, is not a typical "local author book" of engineering days, but one step above that. But still, the purpose is the same.

Usually the argument or discussion is whether to prepare from schweser or CFAI. My suggestion or study plan would be as follows.

I would not recommend studying entirely from CFAI mainly because

1. Will take 4-5 times more hours of study time than from Schweser.

2. One usually needs to revise the syllabi 3-4 times before the main exam. Revising from CFAI books is too painful

3. Too much of information. One needs to exactly know which line is important or which concept is important in an explanation or derivation running for 4 pages. i.e. The gist is not presented clearly

The way I went about it is as follows:

1. If you have an idea about where you want to end up in (say Fixed Income, Derivatives or M&A etc), based on that select a few topics which you want to read from the CFAI books for better clarity. I studied Fixed Income and derivatives from CFAI since they are usually tested during the summer placements.

2. Some areas which are not very conceptual (Set A):

a. Ethics
b. Quants
c. FSA (Financial Statement analysis)
d. Derivatives
e. Alternative Investments

Some areas which are moderately conceptual or very conceptual are (Set B):

a. Corp Finance
b. Equities
c. Portfolio Management
d. Fixed Income (pretty conceptual)
e. Economics (pretty conceptual)

If all areas are equal to you, reading from CFAI books for Set-A does not make much sense. Reading d. and e. from SET-B makes some sense. However reading economics from Set B will take lots of time.

I, most of the time, used to go through 3-4 initial chapters from CFAI to get a hang of the subject and then shift to Schweser.

Finally, all said and done, if you are planning to pass the exam with good/decent grasp of fundas, Schweser is more than enough. Reading only from CFAI, that too just once, wont ensure a pass. You would know some concepts, but cant answer the questions!

I am planning to head to Schweser only for Level II and wont touch the CFAI books unless I am stuck up somewhere. I am planning to use CFAI books only for reference. And yeah, 98% of questions in CFAI main exams can be answered by studying Schweser thoroughly (I mean there was no need to know stuff from CFAI).

Solving questions is a must. That is the best practice ground. I would suggest working hard on the 3300 questions schweser q bank. I did only 10% of the questions from that, that too in the last 2 weeks. But would suggest one to finish reading a topic and take a test in Q Bank on tat topic and keep doing the q bank now and then to strengthen the concepts. Start with Basic and Moderate level and then slowly shift to advanced levels. Would suggest one to complete all 3300 questions before L1. You would definitely be in a very good position.

Time required:

It depends on your background. Putting some 250 hours would be ideal. I would suggest targeting to complete the entire syllabi once some 6 weeks before exam. I completed just 2 weeks before and it made me jittery and I felt under prepared. Then, after that it has to be 120Q tests from Q Banks + revision of syllabi. Then, slowly start getting used to 240Q tests in a day.

Passing marks:

Target 80%+ in Schweser Q Bank tests (85% if you need to feel happy about yourself) and 65-70%+ in Book 6/7 of Schweser and 75%+ in 100$ CFAI mocks.

Target 70%+ in main exam for a pass. 65-70% range is a bit dicey and may fall in the "just pass" category of school exams. 60-65%: Pray to God

Unfortunately most of what I have written above are things which I did not do and learnt it the hard way. Hope I do a good job when appearing for Level II or god forbid, reappearing for L I.

Also, what I mentioned above as a schedule/advice etc is not to "just pass" the exam or "scrape through" it, but to get a good grasp of the subjects and also to feel very confident before the actual exam. There is a difference between being uncomfortable and passing the exam and being comfortable and passing the exam. I was definitely very uncomfortable before the exam.

Why Nepal:

There are certain issues with CFA in India. I am talking of the CFA from US. Till recently we could not give the exam in India due to some court case etc. I did not follow it much. But I knew we could not give it in India. A week before the test, they allowed the exam to be conducted in Mumbai and CFA did a wonderful job I heard by conducting it at a short period of time. However, I was from Delhi and canceling ticks to Nepal and booking again to Mumbai did not make much sense since I had to anyway spend a lot re-booking. And also giving in Mumbai this year had some risks. There were enough disclaimers from CFAI which made me a bit uncomfortable. One of the disclaimers were like "If the court rules against it the exam conducted in mumbai becomes null and void" and to that level. I was like WTF. So did not take any risks. From this December, I expect the exams to be allowed in India and no more Nepal, Bangkok, Sri Lanka trips for Indians.

Update:

*I passed CFA L-1 with 70%+ in all areas! :)

*Visited my blog after almost 6-8 months. 1st year at A was the culprit. Sorry for delay.

* http://www.analystforum.com/ is a good website for discussions on CFA. The forum junta would keep you on toes.